OREANDA-NEWS. September 14, 2010. Summing up the results of the first half of 2010, Ingosstrakh once again publishes data on payments and debts on subrogation claims.

Major Russian insurers – Rosgosstrakh, RESO-Garantia OJSIC, Strakhovoy Dom Military Insurance Company OJSC, AlfaStrakhovanie OJSC constantly make payments on the basis of subrogation.

After publication of the Ingosstrakh press-releases dated December 9, 2009, March 5, 2010 and April 5, 2010 on companies failing to timely pay subrogation payments, negotiations and consultations with Itil Insurance company OJSC, First Insurance Company LLC, Spasskiye Vorota Insurance Group CJSC were conducted. Partnership relations and agreements on subrogation claims payments were reached with these insurers within the laws on CMTPL and Russian Association of Motor Insurers Rules. 

Though generally the situation around subrogation claims payments is still unsatisfactory. Significant amount of insurers ignore the lawful claims of Ingosstrakh. Despite the fact that a number of companies started effecting partial payments voluntarily their debts keep increasing which indicates either the internal problems of the company or the principled approach – to minimize voluntary payments. Such companies include MAKS CJSC, Megaruss-D Insurance Company CJSC, Intersectorial Insurance Center OJSC, Region IOJSC, Insurance Company Innogarant LLC, RSTK OJSC which were already mentioned in Ingosstrakh’s press-releases as insurers breaking the order of the provision of insurance payments on subrogation claims stated. So far there have been no qualitative changes in the procedure of Ingosstrakh’s claims review on their part. the saidThe said insurance companies keep failing to meet the insurance payment dates use selective approach and demand the provision of supplementary documents not stipulated by the laws on CMTPL and Russian Association of Motor Insurers professional activity rules.

Companies practically not providing voluntary payments and providing them only after the decision of the court or disciplinary entities of the Russian Association of Motor Insurers should be specially noted. The most unfair companies are West-Akras Insurance Company, Rossiya OJSIC, Rosstrakh OJSC, Sportstrakhovanie Insurance Company LLC, Russian Insurance Traditions Insurance Company CJSC, Garmed Insurance Company OJSC.

In connection with the sizable, and as for some companies – the constantly growing debt, Ingosstrakh is obliged to file thousands of actions We are paying your attention to the fact that on such type of cases the total amount of favorable decisions on debt recovery in the favor of Ingosstrakh is about 98 per cent

The following table provides information on the debts of the insurers failing to make timely payments on subrogation claims.   

Insurance Company name

Debt as of December 31, 2009 (Rub)

Percentage of

Debt as of June 30, 2010 (Rub)

Voluntary payments as of  June 30, 2010 for the first six months  of 2010 (Rub)

Payments of the Insurance Companies made after the court rulings for the first six months  of 2010 (Rub)

Per-centage of

MAKS CJSC

62,597,765   

99,00%

75,934,274

20,177,877        

13,691,742          

99%

Russkiy Mir OJSC

47,393,923

97,10%

45,085,212

27,029,614

4,141,304

97.2 %

Rossiya OJSIC

20,270,681

97,40%

28,151,692

850,219

1,404,307

98.4%

INNOGARANT Insurance Company LLC

14,971,873

97,20%

28,103,255

12,577,456

4,450,667

98.2 %

Megaruss-D Insurance Company CJSC

31,135,642

98,00%

27,747,154

16,058,727    

6,301,841

98%           

RSTK OJSC

15,966,604

98,40%

22,417,866

8,616,061

2,482,431

98.6%

Yugoria State Insurance Company OKSC

17,065,977

99,00%

18,557,681

3,346,850

2,685,151

99%

Russian Insurance Traditions Insurance Company CJSC

5,072,634

97,3,%

14,090,508

104,221

256,69

97.3 %

Rosstrakh OJSC

10,964,829

98,2,%

14,188,854

453,721

1,733,479

98.5 %

National Insurance Group OJSIC

16,743,451

98,8,%

13,854,340

14,979,274

2,886,106

99%

TPSO CJSC

1,186,632

97,40%

7,397,478

3,998,739

0

97.5%

Sportstrahovanie Insurance Company LLC

1,097,294

97,1,%

7,307,283

92161

0

97.3%

Intersectoral Insurance Center OJSC

4,071,745

97,2,%

5,138,345

265,138

541,803

98%

ZhASO OJSC

5,274,726

98,00%

4,810,196

4,529,262

533,14

98.1 %

Rosenergo National Insurance Company LLC

5,217,159

97,7,%

4,490,265

529,398

642,122

98%

GARMED Insurance Company OJSC

1,376,261

97,8,%

4,014,438

163,307

423,65

97.9 %

West-Akras Insurance Company LLC

657,044

98,1,%

2,996,808

0

0

98.2 %

Geopolis Insurance Company LLC

2,279,728

97,3,%

2,821,899

2,087,604

295,727

98.1%

Moskovia Insurance Company OJSC

1,958,662

98,00%

2,740,318

1,133,702

386,441

98.1 %

Region OJSIC

1,789,902

97,2,%

2,192,823

596,091

557,12

97.3 %

Regard Strakhovanie LLC

1,073,385

97,2,%

1,958,362

1,237,979

20,419

97.3 %

ZhASO-M CJSC

1,445,110

97,8,%

1,726,105

0

182,694

98.2 %

SOGAZ-Agro Insurance Company LLC

1,794,420,

97,00%

1,364,901

64,213

0

97.3 %